Bypass MST first
Connect the monitor directly to the PC. If DDC/CI works direct, the MST hub or daisy-chain is likely the bottleneck.
If brightness works with a direct cable but fails through an MST hub or daisy-chain, the chain may not be forwarding DDC/CI control commands.
Connect the monitor directly to the PC. If DDC/CI works direct, the MST hub or daisy-chain is likely the bottleneck.
Try one display at a time, disable daisy-chain mode, remove adapters, or lower refresh rate while testing.
When MST cannot pass DDC/CI reliably, gamma dimming keeps a practical brightness slider available.
Start by removing MST from the path. Connect the problem monitor directly to the PC with a single DisplayPort, HDMI, or USB-C display connection, then test brightness control again.
DisplayPort MST lets one output feed multiple displays, but the hardware brightness path is more fragile than the video path. A hub or first monitor can pass the image while failing to forward DDC/CI messages reliably.
An MST hub may route video to every display, but only forward monitor-control traffic to some displays, or none at all.
Some MST chains work after a fresh connection but become flaky after sleep, wake, monitor power changes, or HDR mode changes.
If the MST path never forwards DDC/CI reliably, hardware brightness will stay inconsistent through that chain. Use gamma dimming fallback for those displays so brightness control still works from Windows.
If you need true hardware backlight control, a direct connection for that monitor is usually the most reliable fix.
Sometimes, but it depends on the hub, monitor firmware, and chain layout. Many MST setups pass video while failing to forward the DDC/CI control channel reliably.
No. Some monitors forward DDC/CI through a daisy-chain, but many setups are unreliable, especially after sleep, wake, HDR changes, or adapter changes.
A direct cable from the PC to the monitor is the most reliable path for DDC/CI. If you must keep MST, use gamma dimming fallback for stable brightness control.
Use hardware brightness where supported, with gamma fallback when needed.